What happened
An internal ‘market volume function’ algorithm traded from an internal account, generating wash trades that made up over 90% of reported trading volume between July 2018 and December 2019.
Coinsquare also reported non-economic internal trades worth about 112,000 bitcoin from December 2014 to December 2019, and took a reprisal against an internal whistleblower.
Under the settlement, the CEO paid a $1 million penalty, the president $900,000, the chief compliance officer a $50,000 voluntary payment with a one-year prohibition, and the company and two executives $300,000 in costs.
Scale, from official records
- Wash trades over 90% of reported volume (July 2018 – December 2019); no client-loss figure stated (Coinsquare Ltd. (Re), 2020 ONSEC 19)
The Canadian angle
A Toronto crypto platform. The OSC settlement was approved on July 21, 2020 while a subsidiary was seeking registration. Coinsquare Capital Markets Limited is now on the CSA authorized list.
How did Coinsquare fake its trading volume?
In February 2018 Coinsquare first asked OSC LaunchPad for guidance on registering. The next month, CEO Cole Diamond began pressing founder and president Virgile Rostand to inflate reported volume. On July 17, 2018 Rostand switched on the "Market Volume Function". It placed matching buy and sell orders from one internal account, number 100001. No assets or funds changed hands. Clients could not see account numbers, so they could not tell the trades came from one Coinsquare account.
Between July 17, 2018 and December 4, 2019 the function produced about 840,000 wash trades worth about 590,000 bitcoin. That was over 90% of the platform's reported volume. Coinsquare published the figures on its website and through its API. Data aggregators such as CoinMarketCap then repeated them to the public and ranked platforms on them.
Older functions also distorted the market. A "Market Maker Function" sometimes matched Coinsquare's own accounts against each other, producing about 112,000 bitcoin of non-economic trades from December 2014 to December 2019. From January 2017 a "Market Bot Function" placed more than 10.5 million orders priced so they were unlikely to fill. These were about 30% of all orders on the platform, and over 99% never traded. As of December 14, 2019 Coinsquare had about 235,000 client accounts.
Who raised the alarm, and how did Coinsquare respond?
Users noticed almost at once. A Reddit post titled "Coinsquare Fake Volume" appeared on July 21, 2018. Two days later Coinsquare's support account suggested over-the-counter trades or outside trading bots. On August 29, 2018 it wrote that "[w]e do not fake our volume". Clients who emailed were told about "robo traders" or large orders. The settlement says senior management knew the volume was being inflated.
In early 2019 its subsidiary, Coinsquare Capital Markets, applied to the OSC and IIROC to register as an investment dealer and run an alternative trading system. Coinsquare did not disclose the wash trading during an OSC on-site pre-registration review from March 15 to 19, 2019. That month an employee on the automated trading team raised concerns and Rostand turned the function off. Within days Diamond had it turned back on.
The employee kept raising concerns until October 2019 and then took stress leave. On December 3, 2019 OSC enforcement staff made an unannounced visit, and Coinsquare formally ended the employee's job the same day. The next day the function was switched off. The chief compliance officer, Felix Mazer, had known since March 2019 and did not take the steps a reasonable compliance officer would have taken.
Why could the OSC act against a crypto platform?
Coinsquare clients did not hold their crypto until they withdrew it. Assets sat in wallets Coinsquare controlled, and trades were entries on its internal ledger. The settlement treats clients' contractual rights to those assets as securities and derivatives. That brought Ontario's Securities Act into play: market manipulation under paragraph 126.1(1)(a), misleading statements under subsection 44(2), and the ban on whistleblower reprisals in section 121.5.
The panel called the settlement a set of three firsts: the OSC's first settlement with a crypto platform, the first allegations of crypto market manipulation, and the first allegations under the Act's whistleblower reprisal protections. It noted that sanctions in a first case can be lighter than they might otherwise be. The settlement agreement says future firms that ignore these duties can expect staff to seek more significant sanctions.
What changed at Coinsquare afterwards?
Diamond and Rostand resigned. They were barred from acting as a director or officer of a registrant for three years and from any influence over the platform for three years. Coinsquare and Coinsquare Capital Markets undertook to create independent boards, start an internal whistleblower program, adopt compliance policies, and appoint new CEOs and chief compliance officers. Coinsquare Capital Markets also had to resubmit complete, updated applications for registration and IIROC membership.
On August 10, 2022 Coinsquare Capital Markets signed a pre-registration undertaking with the OSC as principal regulator. On October 20, 2022 the OSC confirmed it was registered as an investment dealer, was a dealer and marketplace member of IIROC, and was approved to run an alternative trading system. The OSC noted this differed from other crypto platforms, which were registered as restricted dealers with terms and conditions. Coinsquare told the OSC that each participant on its marketplace must use qualified custodians, and that its dealer would not offer margin or leverage.
What broke
Fake volume and liquidity signals, misleading statements to clients, and failed compliance and whistleblower controls.
What a user could have checked
- Whether reported volumes could be independently verified.
- Regulatory history: search a platform on Are They Registered and the CSA lists.
- Public questions about a platform's volume. Reddit users flagged "Coinsquare Fake Volume" on July 21, 2018, four days after the wash-trading function started, and Coinsquare's answers shifted between bots, OTC trades and denial.
- Registration status, not just a pending application. Through 2018 and 2019 Coinsquare was not registered with the OSC, and its chief compliance officer was not registered in that role.
- Whether the platform disclosed that it traded on its own venue. Coinsquare ran internal market-making and order-placing functions, and clients could not see which account was on the other side of a trade.
Recovery
Not applicable: no client assets were alleged lost.
Sources
- Coinsquare Ltd. (Re), 2020 ONSEC 19, oral reasons approving settlement — Ontario Securities Commission (Capital Markets Tribunal), 2020-07-21
Supports: All facts and settlement terms · checked 2026-11-01 - In the Matter of Coinsquare Ltd., Cole Diamond, Virgile Rostand and Felix Mazer: Settlement Agreement — Ontario Securities Commission, 2020-07-16
Supports: Agreed facts: LaunchPad contact, Market Volume Function dates, 840,000 wash trades worth about 590,000 bitcoin, data aggregators, Reddit and email responses, pre-registration review, whistleblower chronology, December 2019 inspection and shutdown, Market Maker and Market Bot functions, 235,000 accounts, custody model, sections contravened, warning of more significant sanctions · checked 2026-11-01 - Coinsquare Capital Markets Limited: Pre-Registration Activities Undertaking — Ontario Securities Commission, 2022-08-10
Supports: Undertaking date; applications for investment dealer registration, IIROC membership and ATS approval · checked 2026-11-01 - Coinsquare Capital Markets Ltd.: Notice of Completion of Staff Review of Initial Operation Report — Ontario Securities Commission, 2022-10-20
Supports: Registered as investment dealer, IIROC dealer and marketplace member, approved ATS; contrast with restricted-dealer platforms; qualified custodians for subscribers; no margin or leverage · checked 2026-11-01 - Coinsquare Capital Markets Ltd.: Notice of Initial Operations and Request for Comment — Ontario Securities Commission, 2022-05-16
Supports: Subscribers' digital assets must be held with a qualified custodian · checked 2026-11-01
